A decades-old family holiday cottage in South Australia Attract attention Online after it was illegally demolished amid a dispute with a neighboring property owner, prompting some commentators to say that “prison for all the perpetrators involved” was the only way to achieve justice.
on Redditcommentators shared and discussed coverage related to the Barry Robertson family, who have used the modest cottage on government-owned land along South Australia’s Fleurieu Peninsula for nearly 60 years.
According to what I reported Current issueA dispute arose when a wealthy neighbour, Julian Johnston, questioned the legality of the building and asked for it to be moved.
While the dispute over the hut remained unresolved, the situation escalated. Robertson previously said the structure was destroyed and its contents removed, resulting in the loss of personal belongings and decades of family history.
In May 2025, builder George Lavrentiadis pleaded guilty to illegally demolishing the historic seaside hut – and a second hut next door – both of which date back to the 1930s and have been in families for generations.
Lavrentiadis appeared in the Adelaide Magistrates Court, where prosecutors said he… Faces up to 10 years In prison after pleading guilty. Johnston, who owns the building next door and has plans to build on the site, has done just that He denied any involvement In the demolition, he was not charged.
TCD Picks » Upway Spotlight
💡Upway makes it easy to find discounts of up to 60% on premium e-bike brands
Similar neighbor disputes shared on Reddit show that disputes involving property destruction often resonate with audiences online.
In one case, a homeowner discovered that a neighbor had destroyed his land without consent, prompting commentators to encourage legal action and accountability. In another case, a homeowner’s neighbor damaged his garden while the homeowner was away, sparking discussion about boundaries, responsibility, and respect for shared spaces.
For some online observers, the case raises broader concerns about how disputes involving long-term use of public lands are handled, especially when irreversible actions replace legal resolution.
“Imprisonment for all the perpetrators involved and compensation for the removed building is the only way to achieve justice here.” books One commenter.
TCD Picks » Quince Lights
💡These best-selling products from Quince provide affordable, sustainable luxury for everyone
“these [people] “I can’t keep getting away with this,” said another.
A third summed up the whole situation simply: “Definitely unfair.”
Get free TCD newsletters for easy tips to save more, reduce waste, and make smarter choices — and earn up to $5,000 toward clean upgrades in TCD exclusives Rewards Club.